Michael Morgenstern
The frog and the scorpion. Spoiler alert: They don’t make it across the river.
A Montana Republican legislative leader suggests that the GOP back a sales tax. Senate President and former Speaker of the House Scott Sales said in a recent radio interview that Republicans should do so as a way of eliminating our state income tax.
Given Montanans’ historical opposition to the sales tax idea, Sales’ advocacy on behalf of the GOP reminds me of the proverbial tale of the frog and the scorpion.
A scorpion asks a frog to swim it across a river on its back. The frog hesitates, afraid of being stung by the scorpion, drowning both of them. The scorpion argues logically, that if it did so the frog would drown, but so would the scorpion, and certainly the scorpion wouldn’t engage in such self-destructive behavior.
Evan Barrett
Considering this logic, the frog agrees, but midway across the river the scorpion does indeed sting the frog, dooming them both to a watery death. As they start to sink, the frog asks the scorpion why he would do that. The scorpion replies that he couldn’t help it; after all, he is a scorpion and it’s in its nature.
Apparently, when it comes to a sales tax, the Montana GOP can’t help itself — wanting to impose it even though that might well be self-destructive. Republicans argue that Montana needs the revenue for services, that we need the sales tax to cut other taxes and/or that tourists will carry the tax load for Montanans.
Let’s recall the history. In 1971, at the culmination of what was a four-year battle royal involving GOP support for a general sales tax, Montanans got a chance to vote on the issue. Despite being solidly backed by Republican Gov. Tim Babcock and two consecutive GOP speakers of the House, James Felt and James Lucas, near unanimous Democratic opposition to the sales tax brought state finance issues to loggerheads, only to be resolved by a referendum.
In a November 1971 special election, voters opposed a 2 percent general sales tax while supporting a 40 percent income tax surcharge. And it wasn’t even close, as 70 percent of voters opposed the sales tax, which pushed the GOP into minority status for a decade. The GOP political scorpion stung.
Two decades later, Republican Gov. Marc Racicot’s 4 percent general sales tax couldn’t make it through the 1993 Legislature because of Democratic opposition. This sales tax was mostly a tax shift, getting rid of some individual and corporate income taxes and property taxes while putting just a little into education funding. So, it was put on the ballot again in a special election in June of 1993. This time, voters rejected it by an even larger margin, with 74.5 percent voting against it. The scorpion stung again.
So, here we go again! Some 25 years later, GOP leadership proposes a sales tax to eliminate state income taxes (that deserves to be the subject of a separate column). A recent newspaper column talked about the tourism angle, presuming that tourists could take a big tax load off the back of Montana taxpayers. After all, there are only 1 million Montanans, while there are 10 million tourists a year.
While I cannot now give you an in-depth economic analysis, let me do a little “back of the napkin” economic calculation.
Assume the 1 million Montanans spend 350 days a year in Montana, producing 350 million resident spending days. Assume the 10 million tourist average four nights in Montana, producing 40 million tourist spending days in the state. Tourists then account for only 10.2 percent of spending days, while Montanans account for 89.8 percent.
If that “back-of-the-napkin” analysis is close to correct, imposing a sales tax to get tourist money to help Montanans’ tax burden is political malarkey, with 90 percent of the sales tax burden being carried by Montanans.
In addition, certain tourism-related expenditures are already sales-taxed — the bed (hotel/motel) tax of 7 percent and the rental car tax of 4 percent, reducing further the net benefits to Montanans of a new GOP-supported general sales tax.
So, here we go again. Will the Montana GOP march forward? Will the scorpion sting again?
Evan Barrett, of Butte, retired after 47 years working in Montana economic development, government, politics and education. He is an award-winning producer of Montana history films who continues to write columns and record commentaries, while occasionally teaching Montana history.
